Home · Guides · Gifts for cryptid & paranormal fans
Gift guideGifts for cryptid and paranormal fans
Updated October 17, 2026
Some people do not have one favorite creature — they have a whole bestiary. They listen to paranormal podcasts on the commute, know the difference between a lake monster and a sea serpent, and can tell you which famous photo turned out to be a hoax. Buying for a general cryptid and paranormal fan is easier than it sounds, because they love the genre more than any single answer. This guide groups our designs by the kind of mystery they celebrate, so you can match one to the person.
Start with their favorite kind of mystery
Ask yourself what they talk about most. Is it the creature in the lake? The thing caught on camera? The government file with half the page blacked out? Paranormal fans usually have a favorite flavor, and picking a design that matches it shows you were paying attention. If they are a Bigfoot or Mothman specialist, we have separate guides: gifts for Bigfoot believers and Mothman gifts.
For the lake-monster fan
Lake monsters have a long and colorful history, from Loch Ness in Scotland (whose most famous 1934 photo was later admitted to be a hoax, which fans tend to find delightful rather than disappointing) to Champ in Lake Champlain. Our lake designs are built like sonar screens and depth readouts: a shadowy serpent under a boat silhouette, ripples where there should not be any, a numbered buoy tilting as something breaches below. They suit anyone who fishes, boats or simply grew up near a deep, cold lake.
For the night-vision and chupacabra crowd
The chupacabra legend dates from mid-1990s Puerto Rico and spread quickly across the Americas, and it is a favorite among fans who like their cryptids a little more sinister. Our night-vision designs use glowing green static and thermal imagery: spined silhouettes between livestock pens, heat signatures with the wrong proportions, a ghostly figure surfacing in the grain. They are the creepiest designs in the archive, so they suit fans who also enjoy horror.
For the archivist
Then there is the fan who loves the paperwork: the dossiers, the specimen labels, the maps with circled coordinates. These designs look like items recovered from a research station — a jar labeled DO NOT OPEN, a heavily redacted report, a taxonomy of things that should not have a taxonomy, a radio map with static converging on three unmarked spots. They are a great pick for someone who likes the mystery to feel organized.
Why a phone case?
Paranormal fans collect a lot of things — books, patches, prints — but few gifts get used as often as a phone case. It goes everywhere, it is a quiet signal to fellow fans, and it is practical: every design is printed on a dual-layer tough case with raised edges around the screen and camera. The art is our own original illustration, styled like evidence but never presented as real evidence.
Sending it as a gift
- Check their exact phone model before ordering; every case is made to order for one model of iPhone, Samsung Galaxy or Google Pixel.
- Enter their name and address as the shipping address at checkout. Cases ship within 48 business hours, and US shipping is free.
- Make a free reveal card to text or print, since we do not include notes in the package.
- Returns are free within 30 days if the model or design is not right.
Not sure which mystery fits them? Try the gift finder, or browse all of our cryptid gift ideas.
Matching a design to the podcast they never stop quoting
If you are not sure which mystery they love most, listen for clues. Someone who talks about sonar readings, deep lakes and old newspaper photos is a lake-monster person. Someone who sends you grainy videos at 1 a.m. with "look at the left side" is a night-vision or trail-cam person. Someone who loves leaked documents, numbered case files and redacted reports is an archivist. And someone who quotes a different creature every week probably just wants the most atmospheric design you can find.
When in doubt, choose a design that looks good even to someone who does not know the lore. The sonar and specimen-jar designs are especially strong as pure graphic art, so they work for the friend who loves the genre but would rather not explain their phone case to every coworker.
Three quick questions and the gift finder suggests designs that fit. Every case $24.99, free US shipping, free 30-day returns.
Questions
What is a good gift for someone into the paranormal?
Something that matches their favorite kind of mystery and that they will use every day. A cryptid phone case — lake-monster sonar, night-vision sightings or field-journal dossiers — is $24.99 with free US shipping.
Are the designs based on real photos?
No. Every design is original illustration styled like evidence. None of it is presented as a real sighting.
Do you have designs for specific creatures?
Yes: Bigfoot, Mothman, lake monsters, the chupacabra and a few creatures of our own invention in the field files.
How long does shipping take?
Cases are made to order and ship within 48 business hours. Delivery time after that depends on the carrier.